Within the DEI push of US football, which is long overdue
The graphic was featured on US football social media a simple statement with white letters on a black background: “One nation. A team. Together against racism. “
At the time, Americans hesitated a week earlier from the police murder of George Floyd, anticipating statements about systemic racism in that country. It became impossible for many companies and organizations not to get involved, and the United States Football Association’s statement was intended to reaffirm its values.
For Alex Ross, US football event manager and black woman, this was not the case. What did “united against racism” really mean? How would the association support this rhetoric? She did not know because, with the urgency of making a statement, no one in the association had asked the organization’s black staff for their contributions.
“I saw it and was a bit surprised that the people in the organization, especially those in color, weren’t asked about it when we were most impressed,” Ross told Emox News.
So she called Neil Buethe, the association’s communications director, to discuss it. Both agreed that their conversation had to take place on a much larger scale across the organization. Everyone from CEO Will Wilson to CEO Cindy Parlow Cone and on the org chart received an invitation to a Zoom call with one item on the agenda: Race.
In June around 150 employees volunteered to take part in the “Coffee & Entertainment” call to make the topic more accessible. Most of them listened while a handful of others spoke.
Ilyanna Gutierrez, the association’s media and broadcast manager, shuddered at the thought, but cried at the call as she shared her own perspective. Gutierrez’s experience as a rooter for both the Mexican and American national teams wasn’t that dissimilar to anyone else who spoke about the call.
After that, Gutierrez said, she received follow-up calls from President Parlow Cone, her boss Buethe, and even Earnie Stewart, the association’s sports director, thanking her for speaking.
“It was definitely a moment of reflection for the organization,” she says. “I think many of our colleagues had no idea what some people were experiencing.”
It was a conversation the association had never allowed. It was also one that everyone from ordinary employees to Parlow Cone now admits was long overdue in interviews with Emox News. The association had finally dealt with something that it had ignored for years.
After all, one of the most relentless criticisms of US football over the years has been its lack of diversity both within the organization itself and in the communities it is intended to serve. It is criticism that the association also deserves.
The staff at the American football house has been too white and too manly for too long, despite the sport’s diverse, global appeal. So it was no surprise when the association’s coaching courses looked the same or when the youth national teams were mostly made up of white, wealthy suburbanites.
But to hear it from Ross, who has been with US football since 2013, or Parlow Cone, who took over as chairman of the board last year, this is new US football.
For the first time, it has been said, the association is serious about making inclusion a part of its culture – and that has started to admit its own shortcomings.
“I’ve seen a difference more in the last six months than in the past eight years,” says Ross.
What went wrong with US football’s first major DEI push?
The Zoom appeal opened eyes and it made for many who joined in that it felt like there was no going back to behaving like diversity and that inclusion was not an issue that the association urgently needed to address.
“Coffee & Conversation” was a first step. But if US football changed – Really Change – Action needed to follow.
A Slack channel was set up to discuss how to get more inclusive and staff shared resources on education. The association also conducted an internal survey to evaluate the next steps.
“They don’t want to blind anything and just base it on some people’s opinions,” says Ross. “We wanted to hear from our employees what they were looking for and how the call would affect them.”
They established a new internal task force, the DEI Council, to oversee all efforts of the association to promote diversity, equity and inclusion in the future. Ross, Gutierrez, Buethe and Stewart are part of it along with 10 other employees of the US football house.
You hired an external company to carry out an audit. Then employee interviews and focus groups were carried out. The audit looked at whether employees of the color had allies and mentors within the organization and asked what changes they were hoping for in the future.
Some areas of deficiency were already apparent before the examination. Federation officials knew they needed to do better job recruiting and training staff to better reflect diversity and inclusion. However, according to Pinky Raina, US football’s chief financial officer, the audit will serve as a critical foundation for the association to gauge how well its new efforts are addressing shortcomings.
“It was a roadmap,” she says. “What is the current status so that you can benchmark the organization when creating a DEI plan? In a year if you measure it you will have something to measure yourself against and say, “We achieved that this year with all the measures we have taken”.
However, fans and critics of US football are somewhat skeptical of the DEI Council. After all, the last time US football set up a diversity committee was little more than a window dressing.
A committee called the Diversity Task Force was set up by the association some time after the 1994 World Cup, but as Doug Andreassen puts it, “It was a bunch of white men who said, ‘Well, what do we do now? “The task force had no stated goals – it just seemed to exist.
The white Andreassen took over the task force in 2008 to revive it and turn it into a functioning committee. He believed the group could find workable solutions to help football permeate non-white, non-suburban communities that are often tossed aside in America’s pay-to-play system.
These efforts led to a proposal presented by the Diversity Task Force to US football in 2013 that enlisted established, trusted community leaders as liaison officers to the association’s existing scouting network. These connections didn’t have to be football experts themselves. They would help connect the association with traditionally ignored communities like Spanish-speaking pockets and city centers.
U.S. football never asked for the proposal, and the association didn’t seem interested when it unexpectedly showed up.
“Did US football take it seriously?” Andreassen says. “No, I don’t think you did. I think you were shocked and didn’t know what to do with it.”
That suggestion was ignored, and US football eventually ended the task force never planning to meet with the association or come up with anything again.
“I had several calls to the CEO of US football, Dan Flynn, about the problem,” says Andreassen. “I had no answer at all. I was never told anything. We were just left on the vine to die. I am a thorn in their side, but no decision is a decision. “
The DEI Council will not become another diversity task force, say the association’s members.
First, while the Diversity Task Force was made up of outsiders and could easily be ignored, the DEI Council resides in the US Soccer House and already has the blessing of the association’s new leadership, which includes a CEO and a chairman, both just at the last Year took command of the year.
No longer in the association are Flynn or his right-hand man, commercial director Jay Berhalter, who, according to sources, played an oversized role in association decisions that go beyond the commercial side of the business.
“If you don’t have a buy-in upstairs, it kind of falls flat, so you have the buy-in from Cindy [Parlow Cone] and will [Wilson] helped drive this, ”says Ross. “That is exactly why it is different. These are new steps that we have never taken.”
Second, the DEI Council has already pushed for specific changes.
The association will begin to improve employee training that is specifically geared towards diversity and inclusion, which it has never done before.
The USSF hosted DEI Commitment Week in September, inviting guest speakers and asking departments to brainstorm steps to promote diversity, equity and inclusion. For example, the communications team committed to improving the voices and experiences of the association’s Black and Latino players shared on social media.
Further changes will be made based on the external review that needs to be addressed, and a more detailed plan will be released later this month at the US Football General Meeting.
But until these changes are implemented and fans can see a noticeable difference in the association, skepticism may persist. Parlow Cone knows this and she insists that it is an area where the association can no longer afford to fail.
“I don’t accuse her of thinking that way,” she says of the federal doubters. “We have not led in this area and it is important that we do so.” I mean, diversity, equity and inclusion are not just right or a nice thing. It’s also a strategic business imperative. “
Don’t expect solutions to US football’s DEI shortcomings overnight
However, the DEI Council will not be able to fix all the shortcomings in US football – at least not quickly.
While critics and fans have targeted the federation’s make-up, the biggest complaints and worries are often reserved for the development and education of young players in communities across the country through US football.
If the DEI Council is to help make the predominantly white members of the Federation more inclusive across the country, it is not yet clear how this will be done.
“It’s an internal alignment first, and once we’ve got our own house in order and understand DEI properly, we have the credibility to go there and influence others,” says Raina of the DEI Council. “This is where our role comes in: in the end, we show an example of what ‘good’ looks like in DEI and use the tools that we have learned along the way to give others the opportunity to learn from our experiences.”
The remaining question is how long it will take the DEI Council to complete the desired transformation. After all, this new DEI initiative is not about creating a new checklist. The aim is to build a new culture.
What will a successful DEI Council look like?
“It becomes part of our DNA, part of our everyday lives, so you don’t think about it,” Ross says. “It’s something you do because it’s a habit. You don’t have to check and say,“ Oh, did I look through the DEI lens to make sure we’re inclusive? ”So it’s not going to happen for now it is ingrained and becoming second nature. “
That requires some adjustments.
As recently as 2019, US football had a 59-person Youth Soccer Task Force without a single Latino. The Diversity & Inclusion subgroup in the Task Force was headed by a white man, and the association only added a Latino after being called in for lack of Latino representation.
With the men’s national team missing out on the World Cup, perhaps the biggest outcry from fans came when California-born Jonathan Gonzalez decided to play for Mexico in early 2018 after U.S. football suffered a perceived lack of reach. Critics wondered if this signaled a bigger problem with US football’s relationship with Latino players.
Brad Rothenberg, co-founder of Alianza de Futbol, a US-based development program for Latino footballers, knew Gonzalez for years before the midfielder made his decision. Rothenberg says it didn’t surprise him because, in his experience, at least, U.S. football hadn’t primarily sought out Latinos and built relationships with those players.
“The association can’t get rid of pay-to-play and subsidize all children – that’s bad business,” he says. “But they can afford to be more integrated into their approach to hiring. A real link is missing there. If you don’t have a Latino trainer talking to a Latino family about their future, you have missed an opportunity. “
Parlow Cone, who became president after these controversies, agrees that U.S. football hasn’t done enough to make football the sport of choice for children across the country, and that has to change.
“We didn’t make sure that every child who wants to play soccer not only has the opportunity, but also has a real chance of competition and success,” she says. “I know anyone who plays football won’t make it to the national team or our professional leagues, but I know that I am the person and leader I am today because I was fortunate enough to have the means and having the means to play football. We know that football enriches children’s lives and helps them learn many life lessons. So if children don’t see a place for them in football, everyone loses. “
U.S. football works with giants like the U.S. Football Foundation, Major League Soccer, and others who commissioned an outside study to understand why some children don’t choose to play football or why they don’t play at all.
Once the survey is complete, the data will be used to develop new strategies to reach teens who, according to Parlow Cone, had previously been excluded.
“Everyone likes to point to pay-to-play that we all know is an obstacle, but it’s not the only obstacle because I don’t think we’re the most expensive sport,” says Parlow Cone. “So is it access? Is it facilities? Don’t they see themselves as part of football in America? We have to dig deeper and to my knowledge there has not yet been such a survey. “
The association has already made changes to get in touch with Spanish speakers.
A newly created bilingual position is currently being hired in the communications department to increase and monitor the reach of the Spanish-speaking language. This could lead to the relaunch of the now defunct Spanish social media accounts of US football, which were closed in 2019. Ultimately, however, this decision will belong to the new employee who will be responsible for working with Spanish media companies.
Last year, US football launched coaching courses in Spanish to remove the language barrier in coach education.
In other words, while US football is changing, it will take time to see results. At the moment, the members of the covenant ask for patience.
“Top-down, we’re just listening to our people and figuring out where to make changes,” says Parlow Cone. “We’ve had a lot of reports of the toxic environment at the Soccer House and it’s about saying, OK, as new leadership, let’s think about it in a new way.” How do we change that?
“Like everything else, change won’t happen overnight. We’re making progress and we’re moving in the right direction. We see things differently.”
Caitlin Murray is the author of Emox News and her book on the United States Women’s National Team. The national team: the inside story of the women who changed footballis out now. Follow her on Twitter @caitlinmurr.
More from Emox News: